m5广东时时彩:Government backs away from pledge to ban trailing commissions for mortgage brokers

广东时时彩投注 www.dej6f.com.cn Updated March 13, 2019 10:58:29

With an election just weeks away, the Federal Government has backed away from the banking royal commission's recommendation that all commissions in the mortgage broking industry be abolished and consumer groups warn it will leave borrowers worse off.

Key points:

  • When Kenneth Hayne's final report was released, the Government pledged to ban trailing commissions from July 2020
  • Trailing commissions are paid to brokers for the duration of a loan, as opposed to upfront commissions
  • The mortgage broking industry claimed up to 70 per cent of its members could lose their livelihoods

In his final report, Kenneth Hayne recommended all commissions ultimately be axed and replaced with upfront fees paid by the borrower, rather than the bank.

But the Government has announced brokers will be allowed to keep both upfront and trailing commissions for at least the next three years.

That is despite overwhelming evidence that loans arranged by brokers tend to be larger, take longer to pay down and cost more than loans arranged directly with banks or other providers.

With the bank paying the commission, the incentive is for the broker to direct their clients to the bank with the highest commission.

Because the commission is a percentage of the size of the loan, there is also an incentive to encourage clients to borrow as much as possible.

A 2017 study of the home loan industry by investment bank UBS found up to a third of mortgages are "liar loans" — based on inaccurate information that may have been massaged to help the borrower get a bigger loan than they should have been eligible for.

According to UBS, loans arranged through brokers had a higher rate of misrepresentation.

Industry argued 70pc of brokers would lose livelihoods

On the day the royal commission final report was released in February, the Government announced it would allow upfront commissions to continue but would ban trailing commissions, paid for the duration of the loan, from July 2020.

Amid a concerted campaign from the mortgage broking industry, which claimed up to 70 per cent of its members could lose their livelihoods if commissions were abolished, the Government has now relented on trailing commissions.

It said both upfront and trailing commissions will stay in place for the next three years, at which time there will be a review by the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission and the Council of Australian Financial Regulators (APRA, ASIC, Reserve Bank and Treasury).

Mortgage brokers have welcomed the move, with chief executive of Mortgage Choice Susan Mitchell arguing Mr Hayne's proposal would have reduced competition in the home loan market and favoured the major banks, as many smaller lenders relied on mortgage brokers to sell their loans.

"I think that both parties recognise the research that's been done which would imply that consumers are not willing to pay the level of fee with keeping a viable broker channel," she said.

"Therefore, if you were to move to that smaller fee, you would move to an anti-competitive position."

'Government responding to powerful lobby group'

Associate Professor Michael Rafferty, from the School of Business at RMIT, told the ABC it was an extraordinary decision, but one by which he was not surprised.

"The financial services sector is the most powerful lobby group in Australia and it's heavily ingrained with both major political parties," he said.

The Consumer Action Law Centre's chief executive Gerard Brody said the backflip on banning trailing commissions put industry interests ahead of customers.

"Our laws have a lot of problems in them — creating loopholes, creating exemptions, creating conflicted remuneration — because of lobbying by the industry," he said.

"I think that's what we're seeing again today, a government responding to lobbying by an industry sector."

Professor Rafferty said the backdown over mortgage broker commissions pointed to deeper problems and "the continuing self-destruction of the Liberal Party", which he said he was seeing in other areas, like the debate around coal-fired power stations and climate change.

"There's an inability within the Liberal Party at the moment to navigate obvious reform," he said.

'Critical part of competition'

The Treasurer would disagree with that assessment, offering a more pragmatic view.

"The abolition of trail from July 2020 won't proceed as first announced," Josh Frydenberg told reporters at a press conference.

"The reason is, we're concerned about the impact on competition in the mortgage lending market. Small lenders and mortgage brokers are an absolutely critical part of competition in that market."

In a statement announcing the decision, Mr Frydenberg said almost 60 per cent of home loans were settled by mortgage brokers.

"There are 16,000 mortgage brokers across Australia, many of which are small businesses, employing 27,000 people," the statement said.

"The Government wants to see more mortgage brokers, not less."

Mr Frydenberg said an ASIC review of mortgage broker remuneration in 2017 did not identify trailing commissions as directly leading to poor consumer outcomes.

The Government is adopting Mr Hayne's recommendation for mortgage brokers to be subject to a "best-interest duty", just like financial planners.

Labor has also backed away from implementing Mr Hayne's recommendations about mortgage brokers in full.

The royal commission recommended that, ultimately, borrowers should pay mortgage brokers for their services, not banks.

However, the Opposition is proposing that upfront commissions remain paid by the bank, but be regulated so as to be the same across all lenders, although Labor would ban trailing commissions from July 2020.

Topics: housing-industry, banking, royal-commissions, federal-government, housing, business-economics-and-finance, australia

First posted March 12, 2019 18:31:48

  • 一个小学语文代课老师跟咱玩语文?分分钟碾压你![酷] 2019-05-25
  • 宝马任命劳斯莱斯新首席工程师 3月1日履新 2019-05-25
  • 市场经济优胜劣汰,被淘汰的如房地产,造成了资源浪费。 2019-05-24
  • 环境保护腰杆硬起来(在习近平新时代中国特色社会主义思想指引下——新时代新作为新篇章) 2019-05-24
  • 深化创新驱动 浙江获国务院13项表扬激励 2019-05-23
  • 实际情况,你应该了解一下。比如:免费公交与付费公交混搭,其中管理漏洞之多。你应该去观察一下。[微笑] 2019-05-23
  • 胡春华在河北调研督导脱贫攻坚工作(图) 2019-05-22
  • 医护比倒置局面扭转了 2019-05-22
  • 宁夏科技馆科普“粽”宴等你来 2019-05-22
  • 广西百色:乐业消防对乡镇自愿消防队进行培训工作 2019-05-21
  • 看改革开放40年:交通篇——从双腿丈量到抬脚上车 2019-05-21
  • 加强党对意识形态工作的领导 2019-05-21
  • 陕西守艺人丨一场大火后,她带领600羌州绣娘从头开始 2019-05-21
  • “百名红通”归案过半,丧钟再敲响 2019-05-20
  • 俄罗斯足球队50横扫沙特队真是让人大饱眼福,特提精神!俄罗斯是战斗民族名不虚传。 2019-05-20
  • 868| 194| 734| 361| 772| 983| 624| 1| 915| 295|